One part may require a RoHS review, REACH Candidate List information and data supporting an EU customer’s SCIP notification. Some underlying composition data can be shared, but the assessment basis and duties differ. A single environmental pass/fail field can hide which requirements have actually been addressed.
Confirm the product, market and supply chain role
Identify the product, destination market and the company’s role as manufacturer, importer, distributor or upstream supplier. REACH has different requirements for substances, mixtures and articles. RoHS applicability requires a review of the electrical or electronic equipment and relevant exclusions.
Consultants can help establish an applicability register covering product categories, uses, markets, customer requirements and internal owners. A customer’s questionnaire should not automatically be interpreted as assigning every direct legal duty to the upstream supplier.
Distinguish the three requirements
| Requirement | Main concern | Basis for assessment and action |
|---|---|---|
| RoHS | Restricted substances in covered electrical and electronic equipment | Homogeneous material concentration, scope and applicable exemptions |
| REACH Article 33 | Communication of Candidate List substance information | Article-level concentration, recipient and safe-use information |
| SCIP | Notification of relevant articles supplied on the EU market | Duty holder, article structure, substance and safe-use information |
An FMD may provide useful composition data, but its hierarchy and completeness must be checked against each task. Record legal duties, data exchange standards and customer specifications separately, with their sources and versions.
RoHS uses homogeneous materials and defined exemptions
RoHS currently restricts ten substances. Subject to applicable scope and exemptions, the maximum concentration is 0.01% for cadmium and 0.1% for the other nine, by weight in homogeneous materials. Dividing a substance’s mass by the weight of the whole equipment must not replace that basis. Consult the European Commission overview and the Directive and its annexes.
Exemptions require checks of the provision, application, equipment category and timing. The presence of a substance alone does not establish an exemption. Consultants can help define review fields and procedures; the company must provide evidence of the actual material use and product.
The REACH Candidate List is not a blanket prohibition
REACH includes distinct mechanisms. The Candidate List, Authorisation List and Annex XVII restrictions are not interchangeable. Under Article 33, a supplier of an article containing a Candidate List substance above 0.1% by weight must provide recipients such as professional users with sufficient safe-use information, including at least the substance name. Consumers requesting this information must receive it free of charge within 45 days. Individual articles must not simply be diluted into the weight of an entire complex product. See ECHA’s supply chain communication guidance.
Article 7(2) contains a separate ECHA notification duty involving both a concentration above 0.1% and a total substance quantity above one tonne per year, with applicable exemptions. That tonnage threshold must not be transferred to Article 33 or SCIP. See ECHA’s notification guidance.
Establish who has the SCIP duty
SCIP was established under the Waste Framework Directive. Relevant duty holders supplying articles containing Candidate List substances above 0.1% by weight on the EU market must assess their obligations. Non-EU suppliers often need to provide EU importers with composition, article structure and safe-use information; that does not automatically make them direct notification duty holders. See ECHA’s SCIP information.
When implementing GPM or supplier management, assess whether SCIP data collection is needed. Collecting data, generating an exchange file and completing an official notification are separate activities, requiring separate confirmation of system support and responsibilities.
Combine professional review with system support
Consultants can help define applicability rules, list versions, concentration bases, exemption reviews and escalation routes, then train reviewers using practical cases. Each conclusion should be traceable to the product use, data source, requirements and approval evidence.
Startrust’s supplier management module supports survey responses and attachments, raw material composition completeness checks and substance compliance checks. Configure rules for the agreed scope and retain a pending status where evidence is insufficient. Product applicability, specialized uses and exemptions still require qualified review.
When requirements change, identify relevant substances and parts, arrange updated surveys and track corrections, reviews and improvement actions. Automatic impact analysis, version links or notification integrations should be assessed explicitly as implementation requirements. Supplier update and improvement obligations can also be incorporated into purchasing agreements and performance processes through sustainable procurement consulting.
Further reading
- Preparing and reviewing FMD data
- Connecting declaration standards with customer formats
- Implementing consulting and GPM support
Official references
- European Commission RoHS overview
- RoHS Directive 2011/65/EU
- ECHA communication in the supply chain
- ECHA notification of substances in articles
- ECHA SCIP database
Sources checked: November 18, 2026.
